Skinny Legs

Located in the charming Connections East Shopping Center of Coral Bay, Skinny Legs Bar & Grill is a vibrant local gem that perfectly captures the laid-back island spirit of St John. This beloved establishment has been a staple since the 1990s, seamlessly blending the casual warmth of a neighborhood bar with the satisfying flavors of a classic grill. Guests come not only for the food but for the genuine atmosphere—a true gathering spot where visitors and locals mingle in easy camaraderie, often surrounded by the collegiate pride festooned on the walls.

The culinary offerings at Skinny Legs are refreshingly diverse, showcasing island-friendly bar & grill cuisine with delicious twists that make each dish memorable. Whether you’re craving the robust and smoky Jerk Chicken or the fresh and flaky Blackened Mahi Mahi, the menu satisfies with well-crafted options that play with bold Caribbean flavors. The Blue Cheese Burger and the creative rotating Burger of the Day entice burger lovers, while the Veggie Reuben and Veggie Bean Burger reflect a thoughtful nod to plant-based guests. A standout treat praised by many is the Key Lime Pie—richly tangy, perfectly creamy, and topped with a whimsical Santa decoration, it’s been called the best on the island, evoking that perfect balance between citrus brightness and indulgent sweetness.

Drinks at Skinny Legs match the charm of the food, with tropical concoctions like the Strawberry Margarita, the refreshing Tropical Lemonade, and the island favorite, Coconut Swizzle. Craft beer enthusiasts will appreciate the Leatherback Reef Life IPA, a local brew that complements the menu’s hearty flavors. Many diners highlight the value: well-priced, flavorful drinks that don’t compromise quality—a rare find on St John.

The vibe here is unmistakably friendly and unpretentious. The space encourages relaxation with plenty of seating, several TVs for casual entertainment, and a lively buzz without ever feeling rushed or crowded. Guests appreciate the ample parking and the convenience of a large attached gift shop offering some of the best-priced clothing and jewelry on the island. The shop’s atmosphere and the owner’s welcoming demeanor add a delightful shopping bonus to a day spent unwinding and savoring exceptional food.

Real customer reviews capture the essence of Skinny Legs more vividly than any description alone. Lisa B describes it as “a great local bar/pub with a lively laid back atmosphere” and praises the combination of terrific food, well-priced drinks, and excellent gift shop deals. Paul Moniuszko reminds us that while the burgers might not qualify as the world’s best, the ambiance, company, and community spirit more than make up for it, with a tradition that has proudly stood the test of time. Robert B Butler raves about the impeccable brunch and especially the key lime pie, while Pat Bradley appreciates the straightforward, no-fuss meals paired with classic island cocktails and attentive service.

For those who find themselves exploring Coral Bay, whether by design or happy accident like Ray Goodrich, Skinny Legs is the kind of place where a casual meal becomes a meaningful experience—infused with warmth, flavor, and genuine island charm. It invites you to slow down, savor every bite, and soak in the laid-back vibes that define the best of St John’s culinary scene.